Avoiding the Traps of Recruitment Marketing Fallacies
Insights from:
Built to Attract
The Evolution of Hiring:
Moving from Recruitment to Attraction
Kindle edition, paperback and hardcover are available now at Amazon.com.
Employer branding and recruitment marketing are often positioned as the secret weapon in talent acquisition—but too often, they are built on a shaky foundation of flawed assumptions. In Chapter 9 of Built to Attract, I call out a few of the most dangerous fallacies that hold back recruiters, HR teams and even marketing departments from attracting the right talent.
What are some fallacies you should be on the lookout for?
The “We Can Just Repurpose Our Consumer Marketing” Fallacy
“We’ve got a great brand campaign—let’s just adapt it for recruiting!” Wrong. While your consumer brand may sell cars, software or medical services, recruitment is about selling purpose, belonging and identity. Candidates need to see how they will fit in—not how you sell. “Building to attract” means being open to completely rethinking your messaging strategy for talent.
The “Employer Brand Is HR’s Job Alone” Fallacy
Too many organizations treat employer branding like a side hustle for HR. In reality, it’s a cross-functional effort. Recruitment marketing sits at the intersection of communications, brand, operations and talent strategy. Successful collaboration requires respecting and embracing the value associated with shared ownership across teams—and knowing how to structure that collaboration.
The “If We Post It, They Will Come” Fallacy
Job boards. Social ads. Landing pages. All are sometimes necessary but also insufficient. Talent attraction doesn’t work like the movie Field of Dreams. The importance of a well-crafted messaging strategy rooted in authentic differentiators cannot be underestimated. After all, if you’re not focused on attracting—you’re just broadcasting. Organizations need to move away from random (or reactionary) acts of marketing and toward a cohesive candidate journey.
The “We Can’t Market What We Can’t Fix” Fallacy
Here’s the truth: Every organization has flaws. Don’t let internal imperfection paralyze your external storytelling. Almost daily, I help organizations understand the importance of being honest about the work-in-progress nature of their culture. This approach builds more trust than a polished employer brand ever could. Vulnerability, framed strategically, is a strength.
The “We Have to Say What Everyone Else Says” Fallacy
Phrases and words like “part of a family,” “innovative” and “collaborative” are so overused, they’ve become white noise. If you’re serious about “building to attract” you’ll accept—eagerly—the challenge to break away from industry cliches and define what’s unique about working within your organization.
As the competition for talent heats up again (and it’s going to heat up!), defaulting to outdated recruitment marketing tactics is a recipe for irrelevance. Whether you’re hiring nurses, engineers or retail managers, your message needs to do more than inform—it needs to attract.
If you’re ready to rewrite the way your organization attracts candidates, I hope you’ll look to Built to Attract as your field guide.
